'Shocking' lack of evidence on antidepressants for chronic pain
'Shocking' lack of evidence on antidepressants for chronic pain
- Published

People with chronic pain are being given antidepressants with very little scientific proof the medication helps, a major reviewhas found.
In studies, with nearly 30,000 patients, there was "moderate" evidence for only one drug, duloxetine, and just for short-term pain relief.
And there was a "shocking" lack of long-term data, even though the pills are usually prescribed for many months.
But patients are advised to stay on medication if it works for them.
They must not suddenly stop taking tablets without talking it over with a doctor, experts say.
NHS guidelines say:
- Antidepressants can be used for some chronic-pain conditions, including nerve pain and fibromyalgia
- Strong opioid painkillers, which can be addictive, are not recommended, nor are simple painkillers such as paracetamol and ibuprofen
- Exercise programmes and physical activity may help and some people might want to try psychological therapies such as cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT)
Chronic pain, lasting for more than three months, is extremely common - a BBC News survey suggests one out of every four of people in the UK is living with it.
There can be no obvious cause - or it might be linked to other health conditions, such as arthritis.
Experts say brain systems for mood and pain overlap considerably, which is why it has been suggested antidepressants may help. Hundreds of thousands of patients with chronic pain in the UK are thought to be on them.
- Chronic pain 'like walking into a burning hot oven'
At the age of 13, Luke woke up in horrific pain - and a decade on, his condition remains undiagnosed
The Cochrane review, led by scientists from several UK universities, including Southampton and Newcastle, examined 176 trials. But most looked at patients' experience over a couple of months only.
Among the drugs studied - which included Prozac and a cheap antidepressant called amitriptyline - only one, called duloxetine, showed any evidence for pain relief.
None of the trials gathered long-term safety and effectiveness data, which the researchers say is shocking and needs remedying to guide patients and doctors.
Prof Tamar Pincus said: "It's really shocking that we don't have any evidence for long-term use of even duloxetine.
"This is a global public-health concern. Chronic pain is a problem for millions who are prescribed antidepressants without sufficient scientific proof they help, nor an understanding of the long-term impact on health.
"But it does not mean that people should stop taking prescribed medication without consulting their GP."
Clinical lead for National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) chronic-pain guidelines Dr Cathy Stannard said: "This well conducted review adds to the substantial evidence we now have that shows that the use of medicines to treat long-term pain is disappointing."
But it could be difficult to translate results from clinical trials to real life.
"It's equally important to emphasise the many social and psychological influences on the pain experience," Dr Stannard said.
"Existing services, usually outside healthcare, including support with mobility, debt management, trauma, and social isolation, can be helpful for people living with pain - and identifying what matters most to people and signposting to appropriate local support is a promising way forward."
When coming off antidepressants, the medication should be slowly reduced over weeks to prevent withdrawal symptoms, says the NHS.
‘Unbearable’ - the condition affecting one in four
- 11 May 2022
Chronic pain 'like walking into burning hot oven'
- 12 May 2022
Related Internet Links
Cochrane review on antidepressants for chronic pain
(editor-in-charge:Press center5)
Ex-Minneapolis cop pleads guilty to 'aiding and abetting' second-degree manslaughter charge in George Floyd's death in last minute about-face moments before trial starts
How risky is stand-off over Ukraine's nuclear plant?
Asian countries ramp up buying cheaper Russian oil
Russian Nobel laureate 'told to turn down prize'
WhatsApp and other messaging apps oppose 'surveillance'
- FA confirm NO action is being taken against Jordan Henderconsequentlyn or Gabriel after their on-pitch spat... with six other stars involved in investigation over an 'alleged comment' during Arsenal's win over Liverpool
- Fire engulfs Odesa warehouse hit by Russian missiles
- The migrants forced to fight Russia's war
- Civilians killed in Russian strike on Ukraine homes
- FA confirm NO action is being taken against Jordan Henderconsequentlyn or Gabriel after their on-pitch spat... with six other stars involved in investigation over an 'alleged comment' during Arsenal's win over Liverpool
- Austria's far right walks out of Zelensky speech
- Russia sends musicians to frontline to boost morale
- Ukraine accuses Russia of phosphorus attack on Bakhmut
-
Ed Sheeran, Adele, and Harry Styles among affluentest Britons under 35
Ed Sheeran, Adele, and Harry Styles among affluentest Britons under 35Published8 minutes agoShare pa ...[in detail]
-
Searching for clues about Poland missile strike
Last night, a missile landed in Poland, killing two people - the BBC's open source investigations team has been searching for clues. ...[in detail]
-
The WW1 tech helping Ukraine trick Russian forces
Ukrainian troops preparing for a major offensive use a wind-up phone to stop the enemy listening in. ...[in detail]
-
The duo seeking Eurovision glory for Ukraine
Nigerian-Ukrainian duo TVORCHI met in a chance encounter on the street. Now they're coming to the UK. ...[in detail]
-
The ruling marks the first time the company has been compeld to publicly answer to a criminal charge for the 2018 and 2019 disasters, which occurred in Indonesia and Ethiopia, respectively....[in detail]
-
Family's heartbreak at Putin critic's 25-year jail term
Vladimir Kara-Murza's wife Evgenia does not know if she or their children will see him again. ...[in detail]
-
Conflicting claims over embattled Ukraine town
Russia's Wagner mercenaries claim to be in control - but Kyiv says its troops are still holding out. ...[in detail]
-
Ukraine’s missile graveyard 'is evidence against Russia’
Prosecutors want the collection of more than 1,000 munitions to be used in any future court action. ...[in detail]
-
Asda consults on cutting pay for 7,000 workers
Asda consults on cutting pay for 7,000 workersPublished10 minutes agoShare pageAbout sharingImage co ...[in detail]
-
'Wings for freedom' - Zelensky's symbolic gift for Speaker
Ukraine's president gave the speaker of the House of Commons a helmet, as he visited Parliament to address politicians. ...[in detail]
- How nervous are investors about the US debt ceiling?
- Hiding from Putin's call-up by living off the grid
- Hungary's risky bet on Russia's nuclear power
- People try to steal Banksy mural from Ukraine wall
- Sylvia Syms dies at age 89: Actress who starred in Ice Cold In Alex, Victim, The Queen and EastEnders passes away 'peacefully' at a care home, her family reveal
- Ukrainian refugee finds unexpected love
- Wagner deserter admits Norway bar brawl